Which is it!? MTHFR Mutation or MTHFR Polymorphism or MTHFR Defect?

MTHFR issue. What is the proper terminology?

MTHFR Mutation Naming Issue. Who's Right?

There is a lot of talk out there and it is causing confusion.

It is also causing arguments.

I’m hoping this post will cease the ‘I’m right!’ ‘No, I’m right!’ no winner type arguments.

People are calling the MTHFR issue many different things:

 

  • MTHFR Mutation
  • MTHFR Polymorphism
  • MTHFR Defect
  • MTHFR SNP (snips)
  • MTHFR Sequence Change
  • MTHFR Genetic Variant
  • MTHFR Gene Mutation
  • MTHFR Gene Polymorphism

Which one is it!?
Well – they are all pretty much right unfortunately. Unfortunately because it means we are changing our genes and passing the messed up MTHFR gene defect onto our kids who are also passing it onto their kids.

Autism on the rise? Hmmm. Wonder why.

Before I get into this, there are some terms you need to understand:
deleterious: injurious to health and cause health problems
benign: not injurious to health and don’t cause any health problems
bp: base pair
polymorphism: many ‘morphs’, the occurrence of more than one form.
nucleotide: make up the structural components of DNA and RNA. For our use, we are talking about the DNA nucleotides. There are four DNA nucleotides which are: Guanine, Cytosine, Thymine and Adenine

I’m sure a geneticist will smack me upside the head for saying that but I’ve got some support here from a published book on MTHFR Polymorphisms:

Mutation, polymorphism, variant and sequence change – these terms are used interchangeably…to denote the 677C -> T nucleotide substitution.
A mutation refers to any nucleotide change [Cytosine to Thymine, in this case]; a mutation can be benign or deleterious.
A polymorphism is simply a mutation that is common in the population ( > 1% prevalence); a polymorphism can be benign or deleterious.
All the above terminologies are therefore correct when discussing the substitution at bp 677. [bp = basepair] (1)

Let’s define some others and see if they appear correct:

  • SNP: single nucleotide polymorphism.  We have the MTHFR gene, which is 20,370 basepairs long (3), and at position 677 in the gene, we have a single nucleotide polymorphism (because it is common in the population). The single nucleotide polymorphism here is the Cytosine being switched by accident to a Thymine. Oops. Big Oops. Therefore, MTHFR SNP is correct.
  • Genetic Variant: Now this gets more complicated as there are many variations of variant. True, I’m afraid. A genetic variation is caused by variation in the order of bases in the nucleotides in genes.(2)  In MTHFR gene, position 677, we have a Thymine instead of a Cytosine. Yes. Genetic Variation is correct in my book. Expert geneticists disagree with me here? Please comment below. I’ll stand corrected.
  • Phenotypic Variation: As I said, there are variations to variant. Phenotypic variation includes a change in the order of nucleotides but it also includes a shape change of the gene. Anytime there is a change in shape, there is a change of function. Obviously, we have dysfunction in the MTHFR gene at position 677 when Cytosine changes to Thymine. We also have dysfunction when we have Adenine changing to Thymine. But do we have an actual shape change? According to research, yes – MTHFR is a phenotypic variation. It takes some digging and deeper understanding of what you’re reading, but the bottom line – MTHFR and Phenotypic Variants is accurate. Phenotypic variants are also scary – and so are genetic variants. More on this later…

So, it is like driving home from the store. You can take many different roads – each with a different name, but you’ll end up at the same destination.

Stop your arguing about it! 🙂

Dr Ben

References
(1) MTHFR Polymorphisms and Disease, page 13.
(2) Genetic Variation. Wikipedia (sorry – but it is quite a good explanation.)
(3) MTHFR, National Library of Medicine

4 Responses to “Which is it!? MTHFR Mutation or MTHFR Polymorphism or MTHFR Defect?”

  1. Amanda August 14, 2014 at 6:22 am #

    When you say, “we are changing our genes and passing the messed up MTHFR gene defect onto our kids who are also passing it onto their kids,” I wonder if you could go more in depth about how we are changing our genes? Could you give us an example or two maybe?

    • Amanda August 14, 2014 at 6:24 am #

      I can’t believe I just asked you a question without even saying thank you for all you do. Dr. Ben you have made an amazing impact on understanding MTHFR. Thank you!

  2. D fein March 17, 2017 at 3:55 pm #

    Very often polymorphisms confer a benefit. Mthfr is enigmatic. It does seem to increase risk of cancers but also in the case of colon cancer if adequate folate is ingested it decreases the risk and it’s not understood why. Further mthfr causes a very slight thrombophilia clinically significant probably just to a pregnant woman and questionably then but it may help with clotting which in some circumstances including a problem delivery in pregnancy, can be useful. It’s important for pregnant women to take folic acid anyway they know this so I’d skip the alarmism. I do not discount mthfr as a disease factor but the real picture is necessarily more complicated. There are many mthfr afflicted people including homozygosity who are very healthy. Research shouldn’t feed paranoia. It was once thought inflammation was unequivocally bad. Now we know it does have utility in special cases. These are very complex interactions. I’m skeptical that highly prevalent polymorphisms that were so detrimental would persist.

    • Dr Lynch March 18, 2017 at 1:10 am #

      Hi there – you’re right. Polymorphisms are selected for. The issue nowadays is we are fortifying things with folic acid, supplementing and pushing IVF treatments. Natural selection is no longer natural. I am all for supporting our health so we can all have children – absolutely.

      The issue is we are increasing the incidence of MTHFR polymorphisms in the population as a whole – worldwide -and MTHFR incidence is increasing.

      Pregnant women should NOT take folic acid either – they should take folate – in the forms of leafy green vegetables, folinic acid and methylfolate. I provide the science in the video – Folic acid and Pregnancy here

Leave a Reply

Read previous post:
MTHFR Mutations? Help Wanted

While reading this blog post, or rather, rant by me, listen to this 10 minute explanation of why I started...

Close